The Boston Red Sox's recent struggles have brought a spotlight on their ace pitcher, Garrett Crochet, and his less-than-stellar start to the 2026 season. While the team managed to split a series against the Tigers on Patriots Day, it's clear that the Red Sox are facing some significant challenges.
The Ace's Woes
Crochet, who dominated last season with an impressive 18-5 record and a 2.59 ERA, has seen a dramatic shift in his performance. Through his first five starts this year, he's posted an alarming 7.88 ERA and 1.63 WHIP. One outing in particular, against the Minnesota Twins, was an absolute disaster, with Crochet surrendering 11 runs in just over an inning of work.
However, it's not all doom and gloom. Crochet showed glimpses of his former self in his Opening Day start and a subsequent outing against the Milwaukee Brewers. The issue seems to be consistency, with two sub-par performances and that one catastrophic game.
A Team in Turmoil
The Red Sox's problems extend beyond Crochet. The offense, which was expected to be a strength, is ranked 25th in OPS and is tied for last in home runs. The starting rotation, which was supposed to be the team's backbone, has also been inconsistent. Ranger Suárez had a rough start but has since rebounded, while Brayan Bello has struggled in his four appearances. The surprise package has been Connelly Early, who has been a bright spot.
The injury to Sonny Gray, acquired in a trade to bolster the rotation, adds another layer of complexity. He left Monday's game early with a hamstring issue, and his status is now uncertain.
Turning the Tide
To get back on track, the Red Sox need a healthy and effective Sonny Gray. Suárez and Early must continue their recent form, and Bello or his replacement needs to step up. The offense needs to find its power, and the team as a whole must improve its overall performance.
But above all, the Red Sox need their ace, Garrett Crochet, to return to his dominant form. Crochet believes he knows the issue, citing his tendency to make mistakes when behind in the count. He's confident he can rectify this, and his velocity, which is in line with last season, supports that optimism.
A Potential Cause
One possible explanation for Crochet's struggles is fatigue. He increased his workload significantly last season, going from 146 innings in 2024 to 213 innings (including playoffs) in 2025. This could have taken a toll on his body, especially considering his large frame and powerful arm.
While his velocity is consistent, his control has been an issue. He's hit more batters this season than he did all of last year, and his walk rate has increased. He's also been falling behind in counts more frequently.
The Way Forward
Pitchers, like hitters, go through slumps. It's possible that Crochet is just off to a slow start, especially considering his near-good outing on Sunday. However, the Red Sox cannot afford to wait for him to find his form, as they are already languishing in the AL East standings.
The team needs to address these issues quickly and find solutions. Whether it's through adjustments to Crochet's approach, rest, or other strategic moves, the Red Sox must find a way to get their ace back on track and, in turn, improve their overall performance.
